Clarification for Martin

[SimonC]

Bought to my attention, so I could do with a clarification @martin goddard

Retiring from assault
QRS and p46 says    
-1 hit if in woods,buildings,MG or A/c Present
-1 hit if professional unit or mounted cavalry present


P51 says
-1 hit if in woods,buildings,cavalry or A/c Present
-1 hit if professional unit or MG present

Slighltly different. Given QRS and 46 match I'd say that would be it , but could do with clarifying.

P51 version makes Prof Cav much better for the role?

[Moggy]

Maybe either consolidate into 1 statement (clarifying if its mounted or all cavalry) with a max of -2 to count.

Derek

[Sean Clark]

I'll be watching with interest the answer to this judging by my first opponent on the day! 😂🤣😅

[martin goddard]

I will find the rule book tomorrow and  have a say.


martin

[Administrator]

Bump as a reminder @martin goddard

[martin goddard]

No worries Simon.
Will get to it.

martin

[martin goddard]

Let us go with the P46.
Majority wins.
I hope that does not upset any special plans generals might have?
Thanks for spotting it Simon.


-1 hit if in woods,buildings,MG or A/c Present
-1 hit if professional unit or mounted cavalry present

I shall write in my rules. Maybe everyone should do that.

martin

[Sean Clark]

Done!

[martin goddard]

And it shall be verily excised from the sight of the gamer.
Amen Sean.

martin