RFCM

Rules => Conquerors and Kings => Topic started by: martin goddard on September 02, 2024, 09:22:11 AM

Title: Phrygian army
Post by: martin goddard on September 02, 2024, 09:22:11 AM
Phrygian army
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrygia

This might be a nice army.
King Midas (Gordius, he of the Gordian knot) and his later successors.

If this army were built in the Alexandrian (roughly) period it would be an owned by Persia country (a Satrap).
Greek and Persian influences combined.
e.g trousers, bows and colours.
Anyone know a good book about the Phrygian army 4th and 5h century BC?

Maybe as a satrap of Persia, it might as well be a Persian army?

Just some thoughts not the promise of a new army as AK is suing all the oil at the moment.


martin :)
Title: Re: Phrygian army
Post by: Sean Clark on September 02, 2024, 10:57:23 AM
I must say I know vry little abot them. But if the Persians, especially the Achaemenid Persians are anything to go by they are a colourful bunch.
Title: Re: Phrygian army
Post by: SimonC on September 02, 2024, 11:23:41 AM
I suspect not much is known .. you could extrapolate from their Anatolian neighbours . So Lydia is mentioned in Herodotus. Cappadocian is ethnically Greek. Bithynia is mentioned in Xenophon

Thanks
simon
Title: Re: Phrygian army
Post by: Panzer21 on September 02, 2024, 12:11:44 PM
Quote from: SimonC on September 02, 2024, 11:23:41 AMI suspect not much is known .. you could extrapolate from their Anatolian neighbours . So Lydia is mentioned in Herodotus. Cappadocian is ethnically Greek. Bithynia is mentioned in Xenophon

Thanks
simon

That's the first time I've heard Cappadocia / Kappadocia as "ethnically Greek". Are you perchance think of the later post-Successor / Seleucid kingdom? By then most of Asia Minor was a mix of Greek, Persian and native peoples.

At the time of the Persian empire pre-Alexander, they were a distinct ethnic group.
Phyrigia, Lydia etc had some Greek influences from settlements along the coast, but again were not Greeks.

Bithynia was peopled by a Thracian offshoot.

The best books are by Duncan Head - WRG Armies of Macedonian and Punic Wars and his Persia army book for Montvert (probablly rare, expensive).

Neil
Title: Re: Phrygian army
Post by: SimonC on September 02, 2024, 02:03:19 PM
The OP was 5-4c bce. My view would be that most of Anatolia (certainly in the west) would ethnically be Greek. This would the founding for the Ionian Revolt (against Persian tyrants)

My view would be that armies would be 'more Greek' than  Persian. But it would be a mix of Greek , Persian and indigenous types. Herodotus  mentions that the Lydians had excellent cavalry. But Ionian Greeks suffered against Persian cavalry at the Battle of Ephesus.

Thanks
Simo
Title: Re: Phrygian army
Post by: Martin Smith on September 02, 2024, 02:48:00 PM
Quote from: martin goddard on September 02, 2024, 09:22:11 AMPhrygian army
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrygia

This might be a nice army.
King Midas (Gordius, he of the Gordian knot) and his later successors.

If this army were built in the Alexandrian (roughly) period it would be an owned by Persia country (a Satrap).
Greek and Persian influences combined.
e.g trousers, bows and colours.
Anyone know a good book about the Phrygian army 4th and 5h century BC?

Maybe as a satrap of Persia, it might as well be a Persian army?

Just some thoughts not the promise of a new army as AK is suing all the oil at the moment.


martin :)

It would almost certainly be worth asking on the SoA forum, Martin. Duncan Head et al are active on there, and if there IS anything known about Phrygian armies that would be a good point of contact.
Title: Re: Phrygian army
Post by: martin goddard on September 02, 2024, 03:56:07 PM
Thank you for all the information folks.

martin :)